arcana bakeryAt The Old Arcana we make everything from scratch, including a wide variety of delicious and unique baked goods.

Amazing cakes (we love the giant 3-layer kind), pies, cheesecakes, cookies, bars and brownies are created in house daily for our customers who come to eat at the restaurant, and additional items like muffins, scones, and even house-made pop tarts are available by special order for you to pick up and enjoy at home, at the office, or with your favorite group.



Some of our recipes have been passed down from family members. Some are creative creations we’ve adapted or developed ourselves. No matter what is created in our kitchen, you can guarantee they all use only real, whole ingredients. Fresh eggs, real butter and cream are our staples. Our fillings are made from scratch with fresh fruits and spices. All of our icings are blended fresh, never from a pre-purchased tub. No preservatives or artificial ingredients are ever used in our kitchen.


Whole cakes and pies, cookies and bars by the dozen and specialty trays of mixed treats are available from the Arcana Bakery daily. We offer flavors for every taste and the perfect solution for any group event or celebration.


To download a complete list of Arcana Bakery selections, click the link below, then call us at 937-692-0068 to place your order.


To ensure quality, we require 24 hours notice prior to pick up of all special orders. Please note that large orders of multiple items may require additional notice.