From the Bakery Case

At The Old Arcana we make everything from scratch, including a wide variety of delicious and unique baked goods. 

Amazing cakes (we love the giant 3-layer kind), pies, cheesecakes, cookies, bars and brownies are created in house daily for our customers who come to eat at the restaurant (ask your server or check the bakery case!) and additional items like muffins, scones, and even house-made pop tarts are available by special order for you to pick up and enjoy at home, at the office, or with your favorite group. Check out our Bakery page for special order details.

 

  • $5.95
    Dessert of the Day

    Every day, we create a special dessert especially for you. Cakes, pies and special seasonal sweets vary daily. Ask us for today's flavors.

  • $2.75
    Ozro & Ray's Bagel

    Ozro & Ray's Authentic Homestyle Bagels, recognized as Ohio's Best Creative Bagel by Ohio Magazine and commended Governor John Kasich in 2014, are baked right here in The Old Arcana kitchen. Order yours in the dining room or to go, toasted with cream cheese or call ahead to order them by the dozen! Ask us for the flavors of the day.    

  • $2.50
    Fresh Muffins

    Freshly baked daily in the Arcana kitchen. Enjoy yours with coffee, or or call ahead to order a dozen. Ask us for the flavor of the day.

  • $3.95
    Morning Coffee Cake

    Freshly baked sour cream coffee cake with a rich ribbon of cinnamon-pecan streusel in the center. Piled high with cinnamon streusel topping and drizzled with a sweet, decadent glaze.

  • $15.00
    Arcana Bar Cookies

    Scrumptiously delicious, Arcana bar cookies are sure to satisfy any discriminating sweet tooth. Choose from our house flavors: Decadent Dark Brownies, Brown Sugar Blondies, Ooey-Gooey Bars, Lemon Bars or Pumpkin Chocolate Chunk bars. $2.75 each (they're big!) $15.00 per dozen.

  • $8.00
    Arcana Cookies

    Choose from our house standards: Chewy Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Sorghum Gingerbread, Mississippi Mud or Mini Monsters. $1.50 each or a package of 6 for $8.00. Makes a great small gift! Watch for special seasonal flavors daily in the bakery case as well. To special order cookies by the dozen, call us at 937-692-0068!

  • $45.00
    Whole German Chocolate Cake

    Rich chocolate 3-layer cake divided with thick layers of crunch-chewy pecan-coconut filling. Serves 12-16

  • $45.00
    Whole Aunt Blanche's Famous Carrot Cake

    An old family recipe: Some have said it’s the best they’ve ever tasted. Moist, rich 3-layer carrot cake with cream cheese icing and crushed pecans. Serves 12-16

  • $24.00
    Whole Red Wine Cake

    A chocolate lover’s dream. Rich, moist bundt cake made with merlot and covered with chocolate ganache. Serves 12-16

  • $24.00
    Whole Morning Coffee Cake

    Freshly baked sour cream coffee cake with a rich ribbon of cinnamon-pecan streusel in the center. Piled high with cinnamon streusel topping and drizzled with a sweet, decadent glaze. Serves 8-10.

  • 24.00
    Whole Pie

    Freshly baked pie on our famous flaky crust. Choose from Bourbon Pecan, Apple Crumble, Cherry or Strawberry Rhubarb (seasonal). Serves 10-12

  • 48.00
    Whole Cheesecake

    Thick and dense house-baked cheesecake with a graham cracker and vanilla wafer crust. Serves 10-12