We care about the quality of our food and we pay particular attention to its preparation. Everything is made in house.  Our daily specials utilize seasonal ingredients and are sometimes only available for a short period of time, so if you see a special posted on Facebook or Instagram, come visit us that day to make sure you get a taste!

Weekends can sometimes be busy and buzzing at The Old Arcana, so there is occasionally a short wait for a table.
If you have a party of 6 or more or if your window of time for dining is small, please call ahead to reserve
a table. Otherwise, grab a coffee and we’ll keep you comfortable and happy until a table opens up!

— 937-692-0068 —



  • 14
    Smoking Goose Meatery Butchers Plate

    CoppaSalame, Soppresatta Italian Salami, Dodge City ham, Cotto Salame, Stagberry Elk Salame, piq & fig terrine, cornichone pickles, Cherry mostardo preserve, caramel corn, bacon cheddar popcorn

  • 14
    Smoked Salmon

    Chilled smoked salmon, bagel, egg, avocado, caper & red onion, heirloom tomato, whipped cream cheese, dill

  • 18
    Lobster Mac & Cheese

    Old Bay boiled Lobster tail, macaroni pasta, lobster bisque cheese sauce, smoked gouda, bread crumbs broiled and served in a cast iron skillet.

  • 15
    Arcana Brisket Burger

    10 ounce hand-ground beef brisket with pimento cheese, caramelized onion, tomato, lettuce on a brioche bun. Served with smash fries with yuzu aioli dip. Add 1 slice bacon.  1.25   

  • 15
    Wild Mushroom Brisket Burger

    10oz hand-ground beef brisket with caramelized onions, wild mushrooms, Swiss cheese, house mustard on a brioche bun. Served with smash fries.

  • 13
    Lamb Burger

    9oz Lamb burger, feta, cucumber, red onion arugula, tzatziki sauce on a ciabatta roll. Served with smash fries.

  • 12
    Cubano Sandwich

    Pressed Cuban bread, garlic mojo pork, shaved honey ham, swiss, pickles, and mojo sauce, beet chips.  

  • 10
    Caesar Salad

    Fresh romaine tossed with Parmesan, house-made Caesar dressing, soft boiled egg, ficelle croutons and herbed chicken.

  • 10
    Quiche of the Day

    Served with mixed greens and a fresh Bakehouse Breads baguette. Ask your server for today’s flavor.    

  • 8
    Side: Winter Greens

    Mixed greens, bacon crumble, red onion, citrus, dried cranberries, pecans, maple balsamic

  • 5
    Side: Smash fries & yuzu aioli

  • 4
    Side: Spring Roll

    One house made spring roll featuring cabbage, spring peas, and kimchi with peanut dipping sauce.

  • 8
    Side: Cheese Board

    A variety of cheeses, with grapes, olives and Bakehouse Bread baguettes.

  • 4
    Side: Maple Glazed Brussel Sprouts

  • 8
    Side: Fall Beet Salad

    Pickled beets, baby arugula, citrus, red onion, lemon ricotta, pickled mustard seed, pistachio.

  • 5.95
    Soup of the Day

    A generous bowl of scratch-made soup to warm your soul. Call us or check our daily posts on Facebook for today's flavor.  

  • 12
    Arcana Sausage Gravy & Biscuits with an Egg

    House made sausage and rich milk gravy, fresh buttermilk biscuits, herb roasted potatoes and an egg your way.

  • 11
    Bourbon Praline French Toast

    Two thick slices of French toast made with thick cut Bakehouse Bread & Cookie Company cinnamon bread. Topped with bourbon praline sauce, candied pecans, and fresh whipped cream. Add three slices of bacon or a house-made sausage patty on the side for - 4. **Named Best of Ohio by Ohio Magazine**  

  • Dessert of the Day

    Every day, the Old Arcana bakers make a special sweet treat to end your meal (or take home for later). Choose from a generous slice of cake, pies, decadent brownie treats, cookies or pastries from the bakery case. Ask us or follow us on Facebook for today's flavors. Price varies. Order any dessert of the day to feed a crowd. Whole cakes and pies, cookies, muffins, brownies and pastries are available by the dozen by special order. Call us to learn more at 937-692-0068.